Comp be sources A and D as evidence for views on the nature of poverty in England during the period 1903 to 1910 (30 marks) There argon many another(prenominal) similarities between sources A and D and the evidence they bemused for views of the nature of poverty in England from 1903 to 1910. Both sources show deferred payment that poverty is a problem and agree that state interposition is the answer to this problem. This is shown in Source A, written by Charles stand, states the broken ar 30.7% of the population and goes on to ordain he is bring charge of the lives of the incapable. This shows that pot at the age were starting to see poverty in the lower classes as an sum up that the government needed to solve. As well as this it is transparent that both sources suggest that some poverty is down to the deportment of the poor. Source D states that 90% of all paupers arrive along one of three roads these being a unload childhood, sickness, feeble-mindedness and unemployment. This suggests the old elbow room of thinking that its the peoples pause that they are poor is beginning to change. However there are many differences between the sources.
The difference in date is a meaning(a) point as Source A was written in 1903 before the social welfare reform was under stylus and so Booth would have a hard eon trying to start the change in attitudes towards people in poverty, whereas the Webbs published their report in 1910 when peoples attitudes were real variant. Both opinions seem to differ on whether the poor give notice better themselves as Booth states the in dividualistic system go forth survive far b! etter in a monastic request cleansed of those who cannot stand alone, however the Webbs say that 90% of people in poverty are that mode because of a overleap childhood, sickness and feeble-mindedness or unemployment which suggests if they were given the observe they could turn their animation around. Finally both sources have different solutions for dealing with this problem. Booth suggests that the Government should...If you want to get a full essay, order it on our website: OrderCustomPaper.com
If you want to get a full essay, visit our page: write my paper
No comments:
Post a Comment