Nursing Theories Assignment Paper Foetal Abnormality - 825 Words

Nursing Theories Assignment Paper: Foetal Abnormality (Essay Sample) Content: Foetal AbnormalityStudents nameUniversityFetal AbnormalityEthics in medical care require making decisions between preserving life and taking away an individuals life. Different strands of thought in ethical decision making exist that shape the decisions that are formed by practitioners within the field of medical care. These are utilitarianism and deontological approach. These theories guide the ethical dilemmas that exist in conflict on duty. This is based on four fundamental principles of autonomy, beneficence, nonmaleficence, and justiceCITATION GGa11 \l 1033 (Garbutt Davies, 2011). This essay analyses the application of utilitarianism in the fetal abnormality case study.UtilitarianismProponents of this theory base their decisions on actions that maximize the utility of the individual. This means that the sum of all pleasures that will be derived from a situation need to uphold the basic happiness principle. Utilitarian approach is based on decisions that lead to the greatest benefit to the individual and achieving of total utility CITATION Har05 \l 1033 (Harriss, 2005). This is a consequentialism approach where outcomes are based on morality of the intervention that maximizes pleasure and reduces pain. Every decision that a medical practitioner arrives at is based on a balance between benefits and harms without considering other factors like past experiences or evidence CITATION Rac12 \l 1033 (Rachels Rachels, 2012). This means that the healthcare system and resources need to be used to achieve the best outcome to the patient. In making medical decisions practitioners are required to weigh circumstances and the state of the decisions to determine the benefit that the result of the decision will bring to the patient.DeontologyMandal, Ponnambath, Parija, (2016) suggest that deontology is an ethics of duty that looks at the morality of the action and the nature of the action. This means that the decision may be good for the individual but may not produce a benefit for the society CITATION Nor09 \l 1033 (Norcross, 2009). This means that the relationship between the doctor and the patient is deontological in nature to control medical negligence. This means that the doctor should consult the patient and give all the available options to allow the patient to make a decision on which course of action that can be taken.Application of utilitarianism on the recommendationFrom the utilitarian approach, two courses of action can be weighed against each other to determine the pain and pleasure that each action will bring. The action that brings the highest number of utilities is the one that will be adopted. This should be a balance between the degree of pain and pleasure that the individual will receive from a certain action that is taken towards the individual CITATION Mil111 \l 1033 (Mill, 2011). The decision that the doctor, the patient and other interested parties in the case arrive at should be based on maximum pleasur e and the interests of all the parties. This means that the decision of a safe abortion or keeping the pregnancy should be based on the feeling of the mother and the life that the baby will lead in case it grows to birth.Consequentialism allows the parties involved to meet the consequences of the situation. This entails keeping the pregnancy and see the baby suffer the challenges of the deformity or having a safe abortion to save the baby and suffer maternal blues that are associated with the pregnancy. Further, the welfare suggests that the rightness and wrongness of any decision is based on the effect that it has on the wellbeing of the society. The childs wellbeing is the determining factor since the parents have to make a decision that will determine the kind of life in future. The decision to keep or remove the pregnancy is thus based on the decision between losing the baby to save it from the worst future that it will lead or save the baby and expose it to a future that will be challenged by life deformities.How utilitarianism will influence the decisionUtilitarianism is based on the decision that maxim...